BREAKING NEWS: “That’s just the truth. There’s no chance they’ll get to go to the Champions League next season and that’s if they don’t get relegated with the way things are going. And it’s because of his lack of charisma that he is not in the same level as Guardiola ” – This is according to Ian Wright as he seriously criticizes Ruben Amorim for lacking one key element he’s never had at Manchester United.
This raises concerns: if that’s how he appears to the public, is he delivering the same unclear messages to his players? It seems something isn’t connecting.
A growing belief that ten Hag may have lost control of the dressing room led Stan Collymore to make a remark that’s likely to aggravate Manchester United supporters.
Stan Collymore shared his blunt opinion in his exclusive column for *CaughtOffside*, stating, “I don’t think Erik ten Hag ever had control of the Manchester United dressing room, to be perfectly honest.”
He continued, “When you win a couple of cups, players might experience a ‘halo effect’ and think, ‘well, actually, maybe there’s more to this guy.’”
However, Collymore argued, “Man United haven’t played with any identity, belief, or authority since ten Hag’s arrival. That’s just the truth.”
Although the truth may be painful for Red Devils fans, Collymore didn’t shy away from reinforcing his stance.
“There’s absolutely no indication, beyond those cup wins, that Manchester United are feared or even respected on the pitch in regular league games anymore,” Collymore added.
He continued, “Players notice these things, and while they have their professional pride, I doubt there’s a single player truly playing for the manager. Not one.”
“They’re playing so poorly right now that there’s zero chance of Manchester United getting back into the Champions League spots this season, and that’s a truly dismal situation.”
The criticism directed at Erik ten Hag’s tenure at Manchester United raises some important questions about his management style, communication, and the overall state of the team under his leadership. Observers like Stan Collymore have suggested that Ten Hag may never have fully commanded the trust and commitment of his players, which is essential for sustained success at a club of United’s stature.
### **Communication and Leadership Concerns**
Ten Hag’s public demeanor, often described as rigid and somewhat impersonal, has drawn scrutiny. His interviews, such as the one shared by beIN Sports, sometimes come across as lacking clarity or warmth, which could extend to his interactions with players. Effective communication is a cornerstone of leadership, and the perception that Ten Hag struggles in this area raises doubts about his ability to inspire and unify the dressing room.
Comparisons to managers like Pep Guardiola, Mikel Arteta, and even Arne Slot underscore the gap in fostering team cohesion. These managers are lauded for their ability to communicate a clear vision and create a strong sense of purpose, something that critics argue Ten Hag has yet to achieve at Old Trafford.
### **Dressing Room Dynamics**
Stan Collymore’s assertion that Ten Hag may never have had control of the dressing room aligns with recurring reports of player unrest and inconsistent performances. While early successes, such as the domestic cup victories, provided a temporary boost, they have not translated into a clear identity or sustained belief on the pitch.
Collymore’s claim that “not one player is truly playing for the manager” is a stark indictment, suggesting a lack of buy-in from the squad. This is particularly damaging in a league where unity and commitment often define the difference between success and mediocrity.
### **On-Field Identity**
One of the most pointed criticisms is the absence of a recognizable playing style or identity under Ten Hag. Manchester United’s performances in the league have been marked by inconsistency and a lack of authority, contributing to their struggles to compete at the top level. In contrast, teams like Arsenal, Manchester City, and Liverpool have thrived under managers who instilled a clear philosophy and ethos.
### **Future Prospects**
With United currently languishing in form and falling short of Champions League qualification expectations, the pressure on Ten Hag is immense. While his achievements with Ajax and early silverware at United hinted at potential, the growing perception of his inability to galvanize the squad could undermine his tenure further.
The club’s hierarchy faces a critical decision: whether to back Ten Hag with time and resources to address these shortcomings or to seek a fresh start under new leadership. Either way, the need for clear communication, a unified squad, and a compelling vision for the future remains paramount for Manchester United to reclaim their place among the elite.
